Tell Chad that you'll cum in her, but everyone else will use condoms

From Create Your Own Story

Wait, you could get this little cunt knocked up if you blow in her? Well, it's not like you are an idiot, you know that you don't have to come inside a girl to make her pregnant, fucking her and not blowing your load into her is enough too. So, too late now anyway. "Well...", you answer him with a dirty grin as you keep on fucking his little sister's tight twat. "... you should have... haaa... thought about this sooner."

Katy's cunt feels too good for you to pull out now anyway, you are all set on blowing your cream into her tiny cunt. Though you have more stamina than the first time, when you fucked your sister, the thought of knocking up Katy drives you over the edge. You are about to blow in the preteen's pussy, feeling your cock twitching and your balls tingling.

Neither do you hear Katy moaning from pain and shame, nor Chad whining about what is happening, you only focus on the feeling of blowing deep inside her. With long punishing strokes you slam into her then explode, shooting your cum into Katy's formerly virgin pussy, filling her with your hot cream.

Then, before you've even finished your orgasm, you get punched in the face.

Your nose bloodied and your cock suddenly cold you open your eyes laying on the ground with Chad standing over you. "Listen, you can fuck her and ram her as much as you want, but you use a rubber from now on. Got it?"

You only nod numbly only barely noticing the pack of condoms thrown onto your stomach.

Soon the mood is back up and you are pulled to your feet, while one of your teammates, equipped with a rubber over his cock, buries his dick inside the squealing Katy. What now?