Take her back to the party and show her exactly what's going on

From Create Your Own Story

You set down your beer and offer your hand to Katy.

"Come on, I'll show you what kind of parties your brother throws."

Katy hesitates, but takes your hand. "Will I get in trouble for going to the party? Chad always tells me I can't even be anywhere near home."

"Don't worry," you assure her. "Everyone will be happy to see you." Except for Chad, you think to yourself.

"Okay!" She squeezes your hand a little, then follows you back upstairs.

As you get closer to the room, you can hear people chanting. "Chad! Chad! Chad!"

"It sounds like my brother is having fun," Katy says, smiling at you. Then you walk into the room.

Chad it fucking Miranda, apparently going after whoever had taken her after you. He's so distracted by what he's doing, and so are the other guys that are watching, that they don't notice your return, nor your guest.

"Chad!" Katy yells out. She sounds shocked. She looks shocked.

Chad appears momentarily lost, then looks around before noticing Katy standing next to you. He immediately pulls out of Miranda and stands up, glancing around trying to find pants.

"Katy, what are you doing here?!" He says, his face going white. "You shouldn't be here!"

"You... you shouldn't be doing stuff to that girl." She points at Miranda, who just kind of looks dazed lying there with cum dripping out of her. "She's younger than me!"

Chad looks around desperately, running his hand through his hair. "Okay, sorry guys, but the party is over."

A chorus of angry groans arise from the rest of the football team. Most of them hadn't gotten a crack at Miranda yet.