Help Adam score with Shayla so you can get alone with Kara.
From Create Your Own Story
Without showing your serious disappointment, you nod at Adam. "She's hot, but not really my type." You bite your tongue a little to keep yourself from laughing. "I'd really like to help you fuck her tonight," you lie again. "It's now or never, huh? When we're off at college you won't have so many chances."
Adam grins ear to ear, clearly a little surprised at your offer and total rejection of Shayla. "Wow, you'd do that? I would be so forever indebted to you, man."
At this, the sting of losing a chance with Shayla ebbs - now even if Adam finds out about you and Kara, you'll have this favor on the back burner to keep him from flipping out. Yeah, this was a smart decision. "Really, all we have to do is keep Kara busy and get Shayla up here alone with you. Want me to go down there?"
"Shit... what if she doesn't go for me?"
It's a legitimate concern; Adam isn't unattractive, but Shayla could do better.
