Go directly to Spongebob's house and search it while he's at work
From Create Your Own Story
So you searched Spongebob's house. When you first broke in, you hear the meow of Gary, and before he could do anything, you drugged his snail food, sending him into a deep sleep. You start the search going in to his bedroom and rip open the drawers. You come across neatly folded underwear with Spongebob's initials on it. You pull them all out and to your suprise, there's a golden pistol underneath the undies. You put on a glove before you grab the pistol. It seems to have never been used, but you wonder why Spongebob would have it. You put the gun back and make your way into his bathroom. You go to the medicine cabinet and see a bunch of pain-killers. You then see on the counter, filled out papers for Spongebob's parents. LIFE INSURANCE. The papers are dated two months. You are shocked at what you see as you snap photos of the gun and papers before heading back downstairs.
Since Sponge won't be home anytime soon, you figure you'll make yourself a quick sandwich before heading out, you walk over the still knocked out Gary as you into the kitchen to prepare a sandwich. Just when you're done with making it, you hear the front door opening. To your suprise, it's Patrick, who apparently has a key to Spongebob's house. Patrick doesn't seem to notice you as he makes his way upstairs. You:
