Cross the bridge with Natalie going first
From Create Your Own Story
You encourage Natalie to go first. She doesn't want to at first, but you promise to help her out if there's a trap. It looks like she's about to turn this into an argument, but then the buzzer sounds, indicating that the men have been released and will be coming to fuck your brains out if they catch you. Natalie decides it's not worth the delay and heads out across the bridge, with you following a little ways behind her. When she reaches the middle of the bridge, it drops out from under her and she falls into a net which closes around her, suspending her just above the water's surface. She cries out in surprise and panic as she falls, probably giving away your position to anyone nearby.
You now have to make a choice. Do you delay and help Natalie out like you said you would, or do you jump across the narrow gap and leave her to the Hunters?