A deal is a deal, but filming it wasn't part of the deal

From Create Your Own Story

"I'm not saying you can't have her, but I don't think you should do any filming," you insist. He gives you a skeptical look, so you continue: "Who would you show anyway? Friends at school? It would just get back to Adam and then we can't come back. You know, for more of this." Smirking, to show you're still on his side in the sense that fucking Kara is a total blast, you finish cleaning yourself up and return to the video game.

"You're right, bro, she's not just a one-time slut. Don't wanna fuck this up. Thanks for keeping my head," Matt says, clearly reflecting on his own behavior for a second before you see him start to arrange himself and Kara in missionary.

"No problem," you mutter under your breath, pretending not to see what's about to transpire and focusing on the video game.

Matt makes it difficult, however, with his initial grunt as he slides into her, exclaiming, "Damn, almost as tight as I imagined. I bet it was fucking heaven breaking into this first, if it's still this good now."

He's quieter for the rest of the fucking, but you still can't help but wonder what it would have been like if you'd taken Kara's virginity on your own, without alcohol and without Matt. Now you'll never find out.

The End.