Ungtss
From Rationalwikiwki
(Difference between revisions)
Hans Johnson (Talk | contribs) m |
Hans Johnson (Talk | contribs) (→Notes and references: rewording. hm. still sounds awkward) |
||
| (8 intermediate revisions not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| - | |||
{{Stalkbox| | {{Stalkbox| | ||
|date= 2-18-08 | |date= 2-18-08 | ||
| Line 9: | Line 8: | ||
|misc= creationist(?) | |misc= creationist(?) | ||
}} | }} | ||
| - | '''Ungtss''' only lasted for five days on [[RationalWiki]],<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[1]]]</sup> but he is notable for touching off a small furor | + | '''Ungtss''' only lasted for five days on [[RationalWiki]],<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[1]]]</sup> but he is notable for touching off a small furor across several of its talk pages. |
After making several edits that were interpreted as vaguely pro-creationist, the more reactionary editors became suspicious of his motives and he was accused of being a stealth creationist.<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[2]]]</sup><sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[6]]]</sup> (Despite his supposed religious bent, Ungtss proved himself to both friendly and well-spoken,<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[3]]]</sup> and remained fairly calm throughout discussions.) | After making several edits that were interpreted as vaguely pro-creationist, the more reactionary editors became suspicious of his motives and he was accused of being a stealth creationist.<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[2]]]</sup><sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[6]]]</sup> (Despite his supposed religious bent, Ungtss proved himself to both friendly and well-spoken,<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[3]]]</sup> and remained fairly calm throughout discussions.) | ||
| - | + | His edits instigated (*gasp!*) unfettered debate on several talk pages.<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[3]]]</sup> Despite Ungtss' amiability and openness, these discussions ended in a complete and magnificent failure of communication (despite the many big words utilized by both sides). | |
| - | Things were pulled to a halt by [[PalMD]], who was fed up with Ungtss and [[malicious block|blocked]] him. The only justification he gave was "[I'm] capricious and cranky, so piss of".<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[4]]]</sup> [[NightFlare]] called foul and unblocked him.<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[4]]]</sup> PalMD reblocked Ungtss, this time with at least a token excuse ("Removing content from pages without discussion"). | + | Things were pulled to a halt by [[PalMD]], who was fed up with Ungtss and [[malicious block|blocked]] him. The only justification he gave was "[I'm] capricious and cranky, so piss of".<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[4]]]</sup> [[NightFlare]] called foul and unblocked him.<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[4]]]</sup> PalMD reblocked Ungtss, this time with at least a token excuse ("Removing content from pages without discussion"). AKjeldsen unblocked him ''again'' ("Can't see having removed anything. Refs?"). PalMD, apparently unwilling to provide examples of Ungtss' transgressions, "tries to be nice" and blocks Ungtss -- again -- for 5 minutes.<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[4]]]</sup> [[Radioactive afikomen]] (who was evidently absent for PalMD's first two blocks) took issue with this last block and lectured PalMD on his talk page.<sup>[[Ungtss#Notes and references|[5]]]</sup> |
Although there are currently no blocks in effect on Ungtss, the past blocks he received were more than enough to drive him away. He has not edited RationalWiki since February 19th, 2008. RationalWiki would not undergo any more '''non'''-one-sided debates until the arrival of [[CPAdmin1]]. | Although there are currently no blocks in effect on Ungtss, the past blocks he received were more than enough to drive him away. He has not edited RationalWiki since February 19th, 2008. RationalWiki would not undergo any more '''non'''-one-sided debates until the arrival of [[CPAdmin1]]. | ||
| Line 21: | Line 20: | ||
== Notes and references == | == Notes and references == | ||
#[http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=Special:Contributions&limit=250&target=Ungtss User contributions] Ungtss' first edit was on February 14th and his last February 19th. | #[http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=Special:Contributions&limit=250&target=Ungtss User contributions] Ungtss' first edit was on February 14th and his last February 19th. | ||
| - | #[[SusanG]] was | + | #[[SusanG]] was first to [http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=User_talk:Ungtss&diff=123174&oldid=122221 accuse him]. |
| - | #Relevant talk pages (all links lead to the first section on the page | + | #Relevant talk pages (all links lead to the first section on the page where a relevant post by Ungtss can be found): [http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/Talk:Non-materialist_neuroscience#Sad Talk:Non-materialist neuroscience], [http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/Talk:Logical_positivism Talk:Logical positivism], [http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/Talk:Proving_too_much Talk:Proving too much], [http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/Talk:Creationism#Having_it_both_ways Talk:Creationism], and [http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/Talk:Microevolution Talk:Microevolution]. |
#[http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Ungtss Ungtss' block record]. | #[http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Ungtss Ungtss' block record]. | ||
#[[Radioactive afikomen]] [http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=User_talk:PalMD&diff=124089&oldid=122658 lectures] PalMD about his block. | #[[Radioactive afikomen]] [http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=User_talk:PalMD&diff=124089&oldid=122658 lectures] PalMD about his block. | ||
| - | #Later, in the aftermath, [http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=User_talk:PalMD&diff=124095&oldid=124092 Human's comment] sums up | + | #Later, in the aftermath, [http://rationalwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=User_talk:PalMD&diff=124095&oldid=124092 Human's comment] sums up many RationalWikians' view of Ungtss' contributions. |
[[category:users]][[category:Minor RationalWikians]][[category:Low Drama]] | [[category:users]][[category:Minor RationalWikians]][[category:Low Drama]] | ||
Current revision as of 10:54, 13 March 2008
| Stalk this user! omg, it's a joke... | |
|---|---|
| Joined: | 2-18-08 |
| Real name: | n/a |
| Age range: | n/a |
| Gender: | male(?) |
| Locale: | n/a |
| Stance: | Christian (tolerant) |
| Misc.: | creationist(?) |
| user page -- user talk -- contributions | |
Ungtss only lasted for five days on RationalWiki,[1] but he is notable for touching off a small furor across several of its talk pages.
After making several edits that were interpreted as vaguely pro-creationist, the more reactionary editors became suspicious of his motives and he was accused of being a stealth creationist.[2][6] (Despite his supposed religious bent, Ungtss proved himself to both friendly and well-spoken,[3] and remained fairly calm throughout discussions.)
His edits instigated (*gasp!*) unfettered debate on several talk pages.[3] Despite Ungtss' amiability and openness, these discussions ended in a complete and magnificent failure of communication (despite the many big words utilized by both sides).
Things were pulled to a halt by PalMD, who was fed up with Ungtss and blocked him. The only justification he gave was "[I'm] capricious and cranky, so piss of".[4] NightFlare called foul and unblocked him.[4] PalMD reblocked Ungtss, this time with at least a token excuse ("Removing content from pages without discussion"). AKjeldsen unblocked him again ("Can't see having removed anything. Refs?"). PalMD, apparently unwilling to provide examples of Ungtss' transgressions, "tries to be nice" and blocks Ungtss -- again -- for 5 minutes.[4] Radioactive afikomen (who was evidently absent for PalMD's first two blocks) took issue with this last block and lectured PalMD on his talk page.[5]
Although there are currently no blocks in effect on Ungtss, the past blocks he received were more than enough to drive him away. He has not edited RationalWiki since February 19th, 2008. RationalWiki would not undergo any more non-one-sided debates until the arrival of CPAdmin1.
Notes and references
- User contributions Ungtss' first edit was on February 14th and his last February 19th.
- SusanG was first to accuse him.
- Relevant talk pages (all links lead to the first section on the page where a relevant post by Ungtss can be found): Talk:Non-materialist neuroscience, Talk:Logical positivism, Talk:Proving too much, Talk:Creationism, and Talk:Microevolution.
- Ungtss' block record.
- Radioactive afikomen lectures PalMD about his block.
- Later, in the aftermath, Human's comment sums up many RationalWikians' view of Ungtss' contributions.
