Tell him that his answer doesn't make any sense
From Create Your Own Story
"That doesn't make any sense." You say. "I don't think that you should be so mysterious."
"Why not?" He says with a grin. "Everyone around here knows who I am, so why should you?"
"Actually, that means that I should know, because everyone else knows."
"No, you don't understand, everyone who should know, shouldn't. And everyone who does know, should."
You seize to understand what he is saying, and you are quite doubtful that he is going to give you information.
Do you: