SG/Tell her to play dare
From Create Your Own Story
Determined to get over your embarrassment, you say, “How about that game of dare.”
Your sister opens her legs slightly, so you can just barely make out her pussy. She says, “Since you won, you go first. Just remember, brother, it has to be sexual in nature.”
You nod in agreement. You have come this far, so you feel you have no choice except to take it to the next level. All the ideas that come to mind are very wrong when playing with your sister, so you finally decide on something a little safe. Looking her in the eyes, you say, “I dare you to tell me if you have ever had anal sex.”
Your sister, without missing a beat, says, “I have had anal sex. I thought it would hurt, but it actually felt really good to have someone’s dick in my ass. It was uncomfortable at first, but I let myself relax and came hard when he filled my ass with his cum.”
That was far more than you were expecting, but say nothing. You try to get the image out of your head of your sister having anal sex, but you can’t. It does nothing to help with your erection.
Your sister says, “My turn. I dare you to take off your underwear so I can see your dick.”
Knowing you have no choice, you stand up and remove your underwear, which causes your dick to be grateful to be free. Your sister looks at your cock with a smile. Then says, “You have a gift, brother. You have a really nice dick.”
You sit down and try to ignore your sister’s comments about your dick. You don’t know what she is up to, but you don’t think it will result in anything good.
You think for a moment then say, “My turn. I dare you to tell me what is really going on.’
You see her take a deep breath, then says, “What is going on is that has nothing to do with the sorority. I already got in. The problem, and the reason for getting us naked, is I have been having sex dreams about you for the past week. I cannot sleep, since when I close my eyes, you are there. When I fall asleep, I wake up really wet and horny, but unable to do anything about it, since I share a room. I can’t make noise and risk waking up my roommate.”
She takes another deep breath and says, “You are always in control, but sometimes you make me suck your dick, sometimes my pussy and sometimes my ass. I look at you while I let you do these things to me. I can’t get it out of my mind. So the real reason for this, is I am giving you an opportunity that will never come again.”
You aren’t certain what to say. Then simply ask, “What opportunity?”
She looks at you and says, “I am going to let you fuck me. You are going to choose one hole and fuck me with your dick. If you choose my mouth, I will suck your dick and swallow your cum. I will be looking up at you and you have to be looking back. If you choose my pussy, you must pull out before you cum. You can cum on me anywhere you want when you are ready, but not in my pussy. I am not getting pregnant by my brother. If you choose my ass, I will let you cum in my ass.”
Your dick is rock hard, but you feel a little funny about the whole thing. You say, “I don’t know if I can. You are my sister.”
She raises one eyebrow, then says, “Your dick says otherwise. If you didn’t want to fuck me, it would not be hard right now. If I did not want to have you fuck me, I wouldn’t be having these dreams. Now a word of advice. You may never get a chance to fuck a woman in the ass again. You are the only one that I will allow to fuck me without a condom, so guys have finished in my ass, they have not finished in my ass. That being said, the choice is yours.
You choose:
