Refuse to shoot Raquel
From Create Your Own Story
You raise the gun and point it towards Raquel. There's a look of fear and rage in her face as you look at her through the sights of the pistol.
Sighing, you drop the gun to your sides, turn to the Pirate King and say, "I'm sorry, sir, but I respectfully decline," grinning at your witty remark you continue, "She is a member of my crew, and as a captain I made an oath to protect my shipmates and all those loyal to me."
The Pirate King stares at you in deep thought. Suddenly he erupts in a loud, mocking laughter.
"Respectfully decline? Made an oath? I fancied you a pirate, and now you choose to die honorably like some hero? Is that really your final choice captain? Let me tell you this. One person will leave here alive and if not her then you. Are you willing to sacrifice yourself for your fellow shipmate?"
Without hesitation, you answer, "Yes".
"Uhhh... Not really, no." You aim the pistol at her head and pull the trigger.