Andrew, the baseball player
From Create Your Own Story
You decide to call up Andrew, one of your teammates on your baseball team. You both have known each other since the beginning of high school, and ever since you can remember, you've been salivating over his body. He's built just like you, with an athletic frame, tan body built for running bases and hitting homers, and a taut, smooth ass that's been begging for cock as long as you can remember. Girls think he's straight, but you know from the barely perceptible stare in the locker room that he isn't as straight as people think he is.
You decide to ask him over to work out in your basement together, and he agrees, telling you he'll be there in 5 minutes.
You decide you can't exactly be naked for an innocent sounding workout, so you decide to run back upstairs and change into something more appropriate. You throw on boxers gym shorts, and a tight fitting tank top, as not to freak Andrew out right away.
You hear the doorbell ring downstairs, and you start making your way to the front door. You open up and find ...
