...fuck her in the ass

From Create Your Own Story

'Yes...' you think to yourself, clearly 'little pussy' is the weaker of the two girls, surely your massive cock will elicit quite the pleasing reaction... Well, pleasing for you at least, you know fully well, that it will probably be very painful for her, which makes the idea all the more exciting to you.

Your mind made, you saunter slowly, very slowly, prolonging the moment, over to her. Your erection points outwards before you, still dripping with cum, as you approach. As you grow nearer you hear her whimpers change in tone, into what sound like pleads. You smirk. Tears are beginning to brim in her eyes, the pleading noises don't stop. You smile. you are standing above her now, a few drops of cum drip onto her outstretched rear. Now that you are this close, you notice that she is shaking visibly. The tears have begun streaming. Her pleads grow more rapid and desperate. You grin, almost sadistically, as she begs and cries, and suddenly, her eyes somehow find a way to grow wider, as if she's suddenly realized, 'Oh god, this is really happening.'

She looks you in the eyes, as best she can while both shaking and crying, and gives you a pleading look before you...

Go in for the kill, full on!

Feel some small sympathy, and go easy on her.

Feel a substantially larger amount of sympathy, and fuck her pussy instead.

Feel extremely guilty for some reason, and let them go.

Be Cruel.