Offer the female pirates a chance to join your crew
From Create Your Own Story
You and Raquel step into the hold.
"We could always use more crew members," Raquel says. "I'm highly valued."
"I have no problem with women in my crew," you say. "You lasses put up a good fight. You were just caught off guard by superior tactics."
The former captain of the other ship looks you over carefully. "What about my ship?"
"We don't need two ships," you say. "We'll sell it for gold, and divide the profits among all the crew members -- including the new ones."
The other ship fetches a nice price. Having the women on board improves your men's morale considerably.
"So where are we going?" the former captain asks as the Midnight sails away from the pirate port where you sold her former ship.
"To look for treasure," you reply. While in port, your men kept their ears open and picked up word of two new possiblities -- one about a long-buried treasure just outside of Lisbon, and one about the current secret hideout where Captain Falcao stores his loot. Seems one of the Captain's men had loose lips after a few too many at Marcos Rodriguez's bar.