Cassie panics and allows Jim to probe her ass
From Create Your Own Story
Cassie panicked as Jim's hand clutched the bottom of her butt, his middle finger cleaving her cheeks in two. Her heart was racing faster than she had ever remembered it, she seemed to be able to hear it in her ears. Her adrenaline kicked in, making her live every second at half speed. His middle finger ran over her clean, pink little asshole. He massaged the rim for half a minute before he slid his finger in up to the first section. Cassie gasped in surprise and tightened her sphincter in resistance to the intrusion.
"That feels great!" he declared, his alcoholic's breath nearly making her puke.
He slid the next portion of his finger in then, leaving it several inches in her colon. Her sphincter continued to tighten and push, not knowing how to react to the thick, meaty finger now penetrating her. His finger felt like one of her dildos in size, but the way he was worming it around in her ass was giving her a mixed feeling of excitement and nausea that it was some old creep doing this to her.
"Wow, you must an anal virgin!" he declared as she felt him position his pointer finger over her asshole.
She gasped as he slid the second finger into her, stretching her sphincter in an unnaturally elongated way. He then began to push his fingers in an out of her. It felt like she had a massive dildo or poo that refused to be expelled from her body. Jim pumped her ass with his fingers for a few minutes before he grunted loudly and pulled them out with a wet sloppy pop.
"Wow! I haven't had that much fun in years!" Jim declared, tossing her the large towel "You deserve this!"
Jim left the bathroom with a self-satisfied look on his face. Cassie grimaced and wrapped the large towel around herself. It gave her plenty of cover, keeping her breasts and ass covered by several inches on both ends. She left the bathroom and found herself face-to-face with Mrs. Dowd and one of the sons.
"Cassie, this is Kevin - he's our 15 year-old son." Mrs. Dowd told her.
"Hi..." Cassie said, blushing with embarrassment since she was dressed in a towel, albeit one that covered her private parts.
"Nice to meet you Cassie." Kevin absentmindedly greeted her, glancing up and down her form.
"Dinner is done, so you should talk to Amanda in her room at the end of the hall to get some clothes. Unfortunately your clothes were ruined by the mud." Mrs. Dowd told Cassie.
