Wishful Thinking/The Interrogation
From Create Your Own Story
You return to the Stillman sisters as Becky re-enters Beth's room. She is now clothed in a simulation of an officer's uniform. She has the full outfit, including the boots, gloves, shades and hat. She looks sternly at the naked girl chained to the bed then closes the door. She walks briskly over to the window and closes the curtain. The room becomes dark until a desk lamp is turned on. The light moves around until it is pointed at Beth like an interrogation lamp. "Alright, missy, I've got some questions for you," you hear Becky say in the darkness. "If you give me answers I want to hear, things will go well for you, if not... well," she gives a mischievous chuckle. You hear a whip-like sound.
Beth is getting into the mood of the game. "You'll never get anything out of me, copper," she says with a grin.
"Wrong answer!"
You see a flash of a whip hit against Beth's naked back side with a *SLAP*! "Oooh!" Beth cries in mock harm.
"Now, where were you on the night of the 21st last month?"
"I..." she took time to remember, "I was at home."
"Good." Becky turns the light towards her and you can see her unbutton the collar of her blouse. "Were you alone?"
"No, I was with my sister," Beth answers, intrigued. Another button comes off. "My folks were out for the night, celebrating their anniversary. They wouldn't be home until the next day."
Becky continues to undo her top as Beth tells the story. Becky chides her on. "What were you doing?"
"We were just finishing a late night movie and decided to call it a night," Beth continues, "My sister took a shower while I changed for bed."
"What were you wearing?" Becky asks as the top slips to the ground.
"I was in my PJs, no underwear. I took them off while changing."
"Why?" Becky's arms reach behind, unclasping the black lace bra she has on.
"I wasn't ready for bed yet. I wanted to get a little action." Becky's bra hangs loosely in her arms as she massages her erect nipples.
"What did you do?"
"I waited until my sister was asleep then slipped into her room. She was wearing a silk nightie with panties that night. To make sure she was asleep I gave her a prod. She didn't wake, so I felt around her body. Her arms, legs, her back, then I went for more sensitive areas like her tits, ass and finally her pussy."
"She didn't rouse?" Becky asks with her right hand sliding under her pants.
"No."
"So then what?"
"So then I slipped in the covers with her and moved into a spoon position with me on the inside. I took her hands and guided them over my body, under my clothes. She felt up my tits and worked on my pussy."
"But that wasn't enough, was it?" Her hand is now visibly moving around underneath the fabric.
"No, I had to have more, so I grabbed the strap on dildo she keeps hidden in her dresser, I stripped off my PJs and climbed back in bed. I placed my sister on her back, took off her panties and put the dildo on her. Then I used her to dildo to fuck me."
"Did you cum?"
"Oh yeah," Beth responds evilly.
"Well, now that I have a confession out of you, here's your punishment!" Becky unzips her pants, revealing the strap on dildo. She drops her pants and climbs on the bed. You can see nothing in the dark so you activate the night vision. In the dark, you see Becky feel around for her squirming sister. Groping for her legs, she finally catches them and holds them apart. She then inches her way forward feeling for the pussy. Holding a finger inside, Becky finds the tip of her dildo and lines them up. Beth lets out a gasp as her sister hits the target. "Mmm...." Beth murmurs as her sister slowly pushes in and out.
Becky gradually picks up speed as Beth huffs to the rhythm. "Uhn un un un un.... Mmm.... oh oh oh...." The pace quicken some more, "Oh oh oh... yes... yes... oh... fuck me hard!" Becky is pumping hard as Beth feels around in the dark for her assailant. "Oh oh, fuck me, fuck me! Sis, oh fuck me! Yes!"
Becky is moving in and out like a jackhammer. The slopping sound of a wet pussy being nailed is as audible as Beth's cries of joy. "Oh... fuck me, sis! Yes, oh! I love it! Fuck my pussy! Oh! I'm cumming! I'm cumming! Harder!"
With this, Becky moves with renewed speed. "Yes! Yes! FUUUUUCCKKK!" Beth gasps as the wave of ecstasy overtakes her. Becky slows to a halt, falling next to her sister and the two cuddle.
