Tell her you'll give her and her crew half the treasure if they let your men have access to the treasures between their legs
From Create Your Own Story
"My men were going to spend the treasure on rum and women," you say. "We'll give you half if your crew yield their bodies."
The captain glares at you with utter contempt.
"Oh, really. You think we're whores, willing to give ourselves to your drooling thugs for gold? Ha! We're pirates, and we take what we want. Hand over the treasure and no one will be hurt."
