Katy needs more education in pleasing older kids

From Create Your Own Story

No one has stepped up behind Katy to replace you, so you move back behind her, lining up your cock again with her slit, looking redder than it did the first time you saw it.

"Dude, you can't just stick it back into her like that," Chad protests. "Put on a condom!"

"It's been cleaned off pretty good," you grin at Chad. "And I pulled out in time before."

Chad seems reluctant to raise too much of a stink in front of the other guys, so just winces a little as you sink your cock into Katy again, with a much smaller whimper than her first time. You're hoping her young mouth was sufficient for cleaning all the sperm off of your cock, but you didn't want to downgrade to wearing a condom after going bareback your first time around. You hadn't exactly been making the best decisions today anyway.

Now that Chad had told you that his sister was capable of getting pregnant, you can notice things you missed in her body before, especially compared to your sister's. Slightly wider hips, and curvier calfs. Budding breasts. Katy was still a work in progress, but the signs of budding womanhood were there. Now you could be on the lookout for similar stuff in Miranda as she got older, so you'd know when you had to start worrying about using protection. But that was still years in the future.

Katy moans then, finally cumming after your second time of fucking her. She seems ashamed of it, and surprised. She probably hasn't cum before. She makes an effort to hide it, but you can feel it on your still pounding cock, and it's enough for the guys around to notice as well.

"It looks like being horny runs in your family, Chad!" One jock teases your friend.

You still haven't cum yet, your cock being a little numbed after your other orgasms. Katy's orgasm had almost pushed you over the edge, but you managed to resist the urge, wanting to enjoy fucking her before the other guys got a chance and started to stretch out this tight pussy even more.

You realize that it's close now to time to pull out. It's also close to time for Katy to have another orgasm. You start to pull out, and just manage to get your cock barely out of Katy's tight pussy-

-and then your cock exploded, blowing your load all over her dripping slit. It's hard to imagine that some didn't end up inside of her. Katy moans and shudders as she cums, as if the load on the outside of her pussy was her cue to cum.

"You asshole!" Chad says, taking a swing at you, but he's grabbed by a football player.

"He said he would pull out, and he did," the player tells Chad, smirking.

The beefy jock jostles you out of the way, a condom on his equally beefy cock. "Yeah, Josh kept his word." Then he starts rubbing his cock on the outside of Katy's recently vacated pussy, as if lubricating the tip of the condom with your sperm.

Chad stares daggers at you. While he shakes off the player holder him, he doesn't try to attack you again. You're a little freaked out yourself. You hadn't intended to get any cum inside Katy. But what was done was done.