Have your men and the female crew sneak to where the treasure is buried and dig it up by lantern and torch light

From Create Your Own Story

If the other ship also has a treasure map, you'd better act quickly. With the assistance of the female crew, you locate the spot where the treasure is buried and dig it up hastily and quietly.

After you bring it back to where the ships are anchored, you divide it as close to 50-50 with the women as you can under the circumstances, working by torch and lantern. The wind is favorable for immediate departure, so you give the women a 30-minute head start and then raise sail, not showing a light to alert the ship in the other cove. By morning, you are 30 miles from the island.

YOU GAIN 1 AUTHORITY POINT!

"Nicely done, captain," Raquel purrs. "Do you want to go to Skull Crag, the Rio Amarillo or head for the high seas?"