Good. Take him.

From Create Your Own Story

Your men stare at you quizzically as the guards grab the confused-looking Miguel, take him away and slam the door.

"Why did you do that?" whispers a pirate. "He was our key to the jail!"

You sure feel stupid now... YOU LOSE 1 AUTHORITY POINT.

Sounds like the Trojan prisoner plan lies in ruins. Time to think of something else... maybe storm the jail by night or kidnap one of Lord Colton's relatives.