Call him back and start dating him.

From Create Your Own Story

You wait the requisite few days required by douche male etiquette before you call the number you were given. To your surprise- and satisfaction- it's the real one. The same cat you fucked just a few days ago picks up the phone, just a chipper as you remember. "'Ello?"

"Hey, there, handsome," you purr on your end, chuckling a little bit to yourself. "You really wore me out, you know. You're something else. How about we go for seconds? Cinderblock, Saturday, at eight?"

"Sh, sh, shh..." He murmurs softly right back, interrupting you on the end. "I'm, uh, I'm actually at someone's place right now. Kind of...slept in." He's almost whispering, clearly like he doesn't want to be overheard.

"Oh. Alright, then." You clear your throat and glance at your watch, thinking to yourself. "So...that's a 'no', then?"

"Yes! No, I mean, no, no. I'm interested," the catboy replies, purring a little to himself. "Just...look, I'm a bit of a nympho. If you really want to stand out...I'll stop by your place. Tonight. Have someone else with you. We'll make it a threesome. I don't care who."

"Really?" You almost choke in surprise. Now that wasn't how you expected this conversation to go.

"Really," he confirms. "I'm serious. Look, I need to go, but I'll be there. See you tonight." With a click, he hangs up.

Now you have a choice to make. Who will you bring to have a threesome?