The Scar Bet/Hohenheim Bet
From Adultswimaction
Once upon a time, there was a guy named RedRing and a girl named mgangel124. These two AD members got into an argument one day about a character in Fullmetal Alchemist called Scar. Red (as he was called) argued that the apparently evil character was really good, while Angel (as she was called) argued that he was evil... Thus, the Scar Bet began. RedRing's staunchest supporter was cartoonsrool (known as carties), while Mune_Mune was Angel's ally. In this chaotic thread, Red's supporters and angel's supporters were at all out war with each other with angel creating the *insert names of weapons here* of Doom. When Red, carties or other users such as doingy, acted perverted Mune_Mune invented her Trunk of Doom where she would have them "tortured." The bet was decided when Scar killed several evil characters in episode 26. Though he killed evil people, he killed nonetheless and was declared evil. The losers had to change their board sigs according to the winners. To this day, the ultimate decision is still being debated.
The thread no longer exists because it was deleted in an attempt to archive it.
One year later, there was a similar, but much less chaotic argument over the evilness of Hohenheim Elric, the long absent father of Edward Elric, in Fullmetal Alchemist. Angel led those against him, while venus_df led those supporting him. Angel ended up gaining Mune's Trunk after Mune left the boards for awhile. Angel's primary supporter was bherman, who made crazy crackpot theories to declare his evilness. Venus's main supporters included SilentBark and matrixman124. Angel used her authority over the Trunk to lock up bherman, matrixman124, and cartoonsrool when they got a bit too perverted. In the end, though, Hohenheim was decided to be indefinitely good. Truth be told, Angel had much less supporters than Venus, so there was some issues with dishing out punishment... The thread still exists and somehow, matrixman124 and mgangel124 got board married. The reasons are still under investigation, as are the reasons why she didn't marry cartoonsrool instead, as there had been evidence of a board relationship between them.
