Your men mutiny against you.

From Create Your Own Story

Very unhappy with your questionable decisions as a captain, your crewmen agree that you are unfit for command. The new captain Roderigo maroons you on a tiny island with only a few rations, a bottle of rum and a single pistol. Whether you manage to make it back to civilization is irrelevant to this story, since your career as a pirate is pretty much over anyway.

THE END.