Main Page
From Wikivinaya
(→Goal and Content of WikiVinaya) |
(→Goal and Content of WikiVinaya) |
||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
===Goal and Content of WikiVinaya=== | ===Goal and Content of WikiVinaya=== | ||
| - | The goal of WikiVinaya is to create a free online resource of information on the | + | The goal of WikiVinaya is to create a free online resource of information on the Buddhist monastic discipline – Vinaya. The two Buddhist monastic Orders (Saṅghas) for monks (bhikkhus) and for nuns (bhikkhunīs) each have a Pātimokkha in which the major rules are summarised and it is recited in their communities of four or more every lunar fortnight on the Uposatha day. We aim eventually to cover every rule in the bhikkhu and bhikkhunī Pātimokkhas, each chapter of the Khandhakas and Parivāra (and cognates) individually, and with synoptic examinations of topics that are spread out throughout the texts as well. (Initially the order of the rules will be according to the Pāli recension, I suggest classifying cognate rules from other recensions according to the Pāli order unless anyone has a better idea, if or when we eventually get around to including rules from the other recensions not found in the Pāli we will need a new idea!) |
It is hoped that WikiVinaya will be more closely based on the earliest texts than current manuals in English (using direct translations of essential passages), with a more acutely historical analysis of 'what comes from where' (for a start, distinguishing root texts, commentaries and later traditions) and that gradually it will grow into a comprehensive and well organised library. Now we are just beginning and we invite you to help if you can. There are very similar but slightly different recensions of the earliest Vinaya texts in other Indic dialects, including Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit, Prakrit and Gandhāri, and in Chinese and Tibetan translations, belonging to [[wikivinaya:six Vinaya recensions other than the Pāli|six or seven of the early schools]]. It is not yet fully understood in what way these 'schools' were seperate and on what grounds. | It is hoped that WikiVinaya will be more closely based on the earliest texts than current manuals in English (using direct translations of essential passages), with a more acutely historical analysis of 'what comes from where' (for a start, distinguishing root texts, commentaries and later traditions) and that gradually it will grow into a comprehensive and well organised library. Now we are just beginning and we invite you to help if you can. There are very similar but slightly different recensions of the earliest Vinaya texts in other Indic dialects, including Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit, Prakrit and Gandhāri, and in Chinese and Tibetan translations, belonging to [[wikivinaya:six Vinaya recensions other than the Pāli|six or seven of the early schools]]. It is not yet fully understood in what way these 'schools' were seperate and on what grounds. | ||
| Line 35: | Line 35: | ||
These early texts are so similar in content and structure that there can be no reasonable doubt that they stem from a common source. The Vinaya texts must therefore have initially been compiled before the sectarian period. The Canon was probably re-edited several times, most likely between the 2nd and 3rd Councils (according to the Pāli chronology), and more or less closed after that. Initially we will start with the Pāli Vinaya recension because it is the mostly widely practiced and the initial contributors are more familiar with it but we would welcome contributors who can help us learn more about the other language recensions. Most of these recensions also come with traditional commentaries and manuals from later periods than the canonical texts. The Buddhist monastic Order is the oldest monastic Order in the world (the Jaina monastics apparently do not have a communal ideal so they are not reckoned as an 'Order', although the Jaina monastic tradition is contemporary or slightly older). | These early texts are so similar in content and structure that there can be no reasonable doubt that they stem from a common source. The Vinaya texts must therefore have initially been compiled before the sectarian period. The Canon was probably re-edited several times, most likely between the 2nd and 3rd Councils (according to the Pāli chronology), and more or less closed after that. Initially we will start with the Pāli Vinaya recension because it is the mostly widely practiced and the initial contributors are more familiar with it but we would welcome contributors who can help us learn more about the other language recensions. Most of these recensions also come with traditional commentaries and manuals from later periods than the canonical texts. The Buddhist monastic Order is the oldest monastic Order in the world (the Jaina monastics apparently do not have a communal ideal so they are not reckoned as an 'Order', although the Jaina monastic tradition is contemporary or slightly older). | ||
| - | In its two and a half thousand year history Buddhism has faced many challenges and adapted to them as well as the Buddhist community could. The two most crucial periods of change in Buddhist history are probably the move out of India and the move from traditional Asian cultures to modern Western cultures. Adaptation is natural and necessary but if the essence is not to be compromised clear and thorough understanding is essential. For full understanding a non-judgemental attitude is a prerequisite part of the methodology, or in other words analysis should come before evaluation. The interaction between the meaning and the expression of Buddhist monastic ideals, or between the essential principles and the not-intrinsically-essential means of establishing those principles needs to be understood. It may be that in a different cultural context the same essential principle has to be inculated in different ways | + | In its two and a half thousand year history Buddhism has faced many challenges and adapted to them as well as the Buddhist community could. The two most crucial periods of change in Buddhist history are probably the move out of India and the move from traditional Asian cultures to modern Western cultures. Adaptation is natural and necessary but if the essence is not to be compromised clear and thorough understanding is essential. For full understanding a non-judgemental attitude is a prerequisite part of the methodology, or in other words analysis should come before evaluation. The interaction between the meaning and the expression of Buddhist monastic ideals, or between the essential principles and the not-intrinsically-essential means of establishing those principles needs to be understood. It may be that in a different cultural context the same essential principle has to be inculated in different ways. The academic method is useful for avoiding a priori assumptions in studying Dhamma & Vinaya, but our purpose is not merely academic. The initial contributors to Wiki Vinaya are all practicing Buddhist monks from the Theravāda forest tradition, so for us Vinaya is a devotional practice, something that helps us maintain mindfulness of our highest aspirations throughout our daily lives. Dhamma & Vinaya is the only valid authority for the monastic community allowed by the Buddha after his death. So our practice of Vinaya is for us a devotional offering to our founding Teacher, the foundation of the communal ideal of the Saṅgha and also for our own personal benefit. |
===Adding to the WikiVinaya=== | ===Adding to the WikiVinaya=== | ||
Revision as of 05:44, 1 July 2006
|
Goal and Content of WikiVinayaThe goal of WikiVinaya is to create a free online resource of information on the Buddhist monastic discipline – Vinaya. The two Buddhist monastic Orders (Saṅghas) for monks (bhikkhus) and for nuns (bhikkhunīs) each have a Pātimokkha in which the major rules are summarised and it is recited in their communities of four or more every lunar fortnight on the Uposatha day. We aim eventually to cover every rule in the bhikkhu and bhikkhunī Pātimokkhas, each chapter of the Khandhakas and Parivāra (and cognates) individually, and with synoptic examinations of topics that are spread out throughout the texts as well. (Initially the order of the rules will be according to the Pāli recension, I suggest classifying cognate rules from other recensions according to the Pāli order unless anyone has a better idea, if or when we eventually get around to including rules from the other recensions not found in the Pāli we will need a new idea!) It is hoped that WikiVinaya will be more closely based on the earliest texts than current manuals in English (using direct translations of essential passages), with a more acutely historical analysis of 'what comes from where' (for a start, distinguishing root texts, commentaries and later traditions) and that gradually it will grow into a comprehensive and well organised library. Now we are just beginning and we invite you to help if you can. There are very similar but slightly different recensions of the earliest Vinaya texts in other Indic dialects, including Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit, Prakrit and Gandhāri, and in Chinese and Tibetan translations, belonging to six or seven of the early schools. It is not yet fully understood in what way these 'schools' were seperate and on what grounds. These early texts are so similar in content and structure that there can be no reasonable doubt that they stem from a common source. The Vinaya texts must therefore have initially been compiled before the sectarian period. The Canon was probably re-edited several times, most likely between the 2nd and 3rd Councils (according to the Pāli chronology), and more or less closed after that. Initially we will start with the Pāli Vinaya recension because it is the mostly widely practiced and the initial contributors are more familiar with it but we would welcome contributors who can help us learn more about the other language recensions. Most of these recensions also come with traditional commentaries and manuals from later periods than the canonical texts. The Buddhist monastic Order is the oldest monastic Order in the world (the Jaina monastics apparently do not have a communal ideal so they are not reckoned as an 'Order', although the Jaina monastic tradition is contemporary or slightly older). In its two and a half thousand year history Buddhism has faced many challenges and adapted to them as well as the Buddhist community could. The two most crucial periods of change in Buddhist history are probably the move out of India and the move from traditional Asian cultures to modern Western cultures. Adaptation is natural and necessary but if the essence is not to be compromised clear and thorough understanding is essential. For full understanding a non-judgemental attitude is a prerequisite part of the methodology, or in other words analysis should come before evaluation. The interaction between the meaning and the expression of Buddhist monastic ideals, or between the essential principles and the not-intrinsically-essential means of establishing those principles needs to be understood. It may be that in a different cultural context the same essential principle has to be inculated in different ways. The academic method is useful for avoiding a priori assumptions in studying Dhamma & Vinaya, but our purpose is not merely academic. The initial contributors to Wiki Vinaya are all practicing Buddhist monks from the Theravāda forest tradition, so for us Vinaya is a devotional practice, something that helps us maintain mindfulness of our highest aspirations throughout our daily lives. Dhamma & Vinaya is the only valid authority for the monastic community allowed by the Buddha after his death. So our practice of Vinaya is for us a devotional offering to our founding Teacher, the foundation of the communal ideal of the Saṅgha and also for our own personal benefit. Adding to the WikiVinayaSince WikiVinaya is a wiki, the writing of all pages of the WikiVinaya is principally a community-effort, and the contents of these pages can be altered. Also this page, and any of the other pages. So feel free to change and add things. However, you need to create an account on WikiVinaya in order to be able to edit pages and make new pages. More information for newcomers to wikis can be found at the welcome page for newcomers at wikipedia. WikiVinaya is not the same as Wikipedia, but it uses the same software as Wikipedia and mostly the same ethos. The two differences in ethos are:
To Do
|
