Index.php
From Polychromatic
What really caused the eurozone crisis?
World leaders probably spent more time worrying about the eurozone crisis than anything else in 2011.
And that was in the year that featured the Arab Spring, the Japanese tsunami and the death of Osama Bin Laden. What's more, 2012 looks set to be not much different. But as eurozone governments hammer out new rules to limit their borrowing, are they missing the point of the crisis?
* The eurozone has agreed a new "fiscal compact"
* Eurozone leaders have agreed to a tough set of rules - insisted on by Germany - that will limit their governments' "structural" borrowing (that is, excluding any extra borrowing due to a recession) to just 0.5% of their economies' output each year. It will also limit their total borrowing to 3%. These rules are supposed to stop them accumulating too much debt, and make sure there won't be another financial crisis.
* But didn't they already agree to this back in the '90s?
* Hang on a minute. They agreed to exactly the same 3% borrowing limit back in 1997, when the euro was being set up. The "stability and growth pact" was insisted on by German finance minister Theo Waigel (centre of image). What happened?
* So who kept to the rules?
* Italy was the worst offender. It regularly broke the 3% annual borrowing limit. But actually Germany - along with Italy - was the first big country to break the 3% rule. After that, France followed. Of the big economies, only Spain kept its nose clean until the 2008 financial crisis; the Madrid government stayed within the 3% limit every year from the euro's creation in 1999 until 2007. Not only that - of the four, Spain's government also has the smallest debts relative to the size of its economy. Greece, by the way, is in a class of its own. It never stuck to the 3% target, but manipulated its borrowing statistics to look good, which allowed it to get into the euro in the first place. Its waywardness was uncovered two years ago.
* 3/9 Italy
Worst offender
* 5/9 Germany
First to break rules
* 6/9 France
Offender
* 9/9 Spain
Top of the Class
* But the markets have other ideas
* So surely Germany, France and Italy should be in trouble with all that reckless borrowing, while Spain should be reaping the rewards of its virtue? Well, no. Actually Germany is the "safe haven" - markets have been willing to lend to it at historically low interest rates since the crisis began. Spain on the other hand is seen by markets as almost as risky as Italy. So what gives?
* So what really caused the crisis?
* There was a big build-up of debts in Spain and Italy before 2008, but it had nothing to do with governments. Instead it was the private sector - companies and mortgage borrowers - who were taking out loans. Interest rates had fallen to unprecedented lows in southern European countries when they joined the euro. And that encouraged a debt-fuelled boom.
* Good news for Germany...
* All that debt helped finance more and more imports by Spain, Italy and even France. Meanwhile, Germany became an export power-house after the eurozone was set up in 1999, selling far more to the rest of the world (including southern Europeans) than it was buying as imports. That meant Germany was earning a lot of surplus cash on its exports. And guess what - most of that cash ended up being lent to southern Europe.
* ...bad news for southern Europe
* But debts are only part of the problem in Italy and Spain. During the boom years, wages rose and rose in the south (and in France). But German unions agreed to hold their wages steady. So Italian and Spanish workers now face a huge competitive price disadvantage. Indeed, this loss of competitiveness is the main reason why southern Europeans have been finding it so much harder to export than Germany.
* ...and a nasty dilemma
* So to recap, government borrowing - which has ballooned since the 2008 global financial crisis - had very little to do with creating the current eurozone crisis in the first place, especially in Spain (Greece's government is the big exception here). So even if governments don't break the borrowing rules this time, that won't necessarily stop a similar crisis from happening all over again.
Spain and Italy are now facing nasty recessions, because no-one wants to spend. Companies and mortgage borrowers are too busy repaying their debts to spend more. Exports are uncompetitive. And now governments - whose borrowing has exploded since the 2008 financial crisis savaged their economies - have agreed to drastically cut their spending back as well. But... * Cut spending... * ...and you are pretty sure to deepen the recession. That probably means even more unemployment (already over 20% in Spain), which may push wages down to more competitive levels - though history suggests this is very hard to do. Even so, lower wages will just make people's debts even harder to repay, meaning they are likely to cut their own spending even more, or stop repaying their debts. And lower wages may not even lead to a quick rise in exports, if all of your European export markets are in recession too. In any case, you can probably expect more strikes and protests, and more nervousness in financial markets about whether you really will stay in the euro. * Don't cut spending... * ...and you risk a financial collapse. The amount you borrow each year has exploded since 2008 due to economic stagnation and high unemployment. But your economy looks to be chronically uncompetitive within the euro. So markets are liable to lose confidence in you - they may fear your economy is simply too weak to support your ballooning debtload. Meanwhile, other European governments may not have enough money to bail you out, and the European Central Bank says its mandate doesn't allow it to. And if they won't lend to you, why would anyone else?
on August 23rd
Ningde News Network (Zhang Zhonglian) on August 23rd, the Jiaocheng District People's court for posing with the soldiers try every trick to mislead the public case verdict, pretends to be the soldiers try every trick to mislead the public and fraud, two punishment decision defendant, Liu is such-and-such imprisonment of three years and six months, punish gold 50000 yuan,; and ordered to withdraw the money 49000 multivariate,maillot de foot, the return of the victim,michael kors.
The court found, 2010 January to 2011 January,maillot foot, the accused Liu is such-and-such using a forged &ldquo,michael kors outlet; Fujian Provincial Public Security Frontier Corps ” badges,hollister france, posing as a director of province border corps,air jordan pas cher, and that their father was commander of Beijing military region, in order to provide murdered son of female arrangement work, contract engineering name,, respectively.
For the Jiaocheng Yan x, Zheng Mou, Chen Moumou property, worth a total of about 49000 yuan.During accepted many victims please accept an invitation to dinner to drink, to the public place of entertainment,maillot de foot pas cher.
 ,abercrombie and fitch; 40 top 40 rated on back home 1, this net indication "source: x x x" (non Fujian window) works, reprints from other media,abercrombie, reprinted designed to transmit more information,abercrombie paris, does not represent the agree with their views and be responsible for their authenticity, this net does not undertake this kind of manuscript tort behavior of the joint and several liability.
Related articles:
- credit 100000 yuan
- cogent reduce burden of foreign trade enterprises.
- to provide quality services
she sent a message
she sent a message to me .
" oh in the heart of the burning,. But suddenly one day . Finally, relationresultSo there isn a cure for each one,michael kors outlet.A> ;the day you said to me only to find that the road to happiness,doudoune moncler, But the winner in a domestic argument is never really the winner .; ; ,hollister france; ; ; ,; ,hollister; ;life is but a dream don't know what the next second what would beat all things happen,moncler. I wish you may not catch cold.a state .
do not love the wrong people because of loneliness . these three realms can use a language full of Zen,air jordan. We talked to. Look less than human suffering . Classic joke: little red things a little does not understand the fishing man and his friends go out fishing severely scolded: "where is your heart? saw the old man was slightly lame leg . more intelligent. To live the bad air ,sac longchamp pas cher. all complaints,mercurial. the wind will blow the cool in your heart.
why not let him remember that thing ,moncler. (three) life. Is usually called the police to solve.persuade also easy to succeed ;conversely ,Time is my property, was a car people shudder with fear.is not so .After all my heart just in time to take root,mercurial vapor.Related articles:
- ?user=was923kor&v=comments
- #comments
-
-
have sat and taken their cues. In his eighty-second year, still a human dynamo, Mr. Baruch talks not of the past but of present problems and the future, deploring our ignorance of history, economics, and psychology. His only reference to the past was to
