Stab the tentacle trapping your oar
From Create Your Own Story
With a well practiced reaction, you draw your dagger and stab the invasive tentacle, deep. Feeling your stab stop halfway into the wood of the oar, you hear a terrible shriek as the Squid girl pulls her tentacle back, slicing down the line several inches until your knife is dislodged. That definitely got the point across.
Wrapping her split limb with a different tentacle, she begins a hasty swim back out to sea.
"I'll remember this! You're d-dead! I'm going to fucking eat you." The squid girl spits with as much venom as she can muster
Before she can fully dive underwater, you...