"Let me fuck your asses."
From Create Your Own Story
You and Mike look at each other, then bend over hesitantly. You know from the showers that Tony is big soft, but who knows what his hard Italian sausage looks like.
Turning around, you see that Tony has stripped down. His body is muscular for a senior and his hard cock is a fraction shorter than yours, but thick. Being a top, you wonder if you'll be able to handle it. Tony asks which of you is tighter. "I am," replies Mike.
"Then I'll take Coach Donato first. Save the best for last."
At first, you are hesitant, but you realize that this could be enjoyable...If you let it. Tony walks up behind you and whispers in your ear, "Time for a taste of your own medicine, bitch." So he knows about your flings with almost every player you've ever coached.
Tony plunges into you without warning. You try not to scream, but your hole is being stretched to its limit.
"If you're not the tight one, then Coach Hovey must be impossible! Damn, that's nice."
Despite being a top, you know how to get down being a bottom. You begin to moan, liking the fullness Tony's cock gives you. He even brushes your prostate, making you see spots as you cum across the dirty floor. Tony pulls out, wanting to save some for Mike.
He crosses over to him, but gives Coach Hovey a bit of foreplay. "You never did anything wrong, so I might as well let you enjoy it." You watch as Tony uses his mouth to cover every sensitive area on Mike's body but his cock. As he eats Mike's ass out as you did minutes earlier, Mike moans and begs for Tony's cock.
"He'll never be a straight man again," you think.
"You want it?" says Tony, his body practically vibrating with excitement.
"Yes, please! Fill me with your hot, fat sausage, you Italian stallion! Fuck me!!"
This is too much for Tony to handle, and he pushes into Mike in one thrust. They both begin screaming in pleasure, and after a few minutes, cum simultaneously.
Tony crosses over to you and orders you to clean his prick. You do so, loving the taste of Mike's ass mixed with Tony's cum.
Finally, Tony agrees not to tell anyone as long as they don't tell his father. Of course, he doesn't know that you and his father have had lots of fun together. You agree anyway, and decide that you are done for today. Mike heads home, knowing his sex life with his wife will never be the same. Maybe, just maybe, you can have some more fun with your best friend tomorrow.
End.
