User:Finisterre/proposalspace

From Nomicapolis

Proposals I'm working on

335 --Dayd 18:33, 26 November 2006 (EST)

Any Player may accuse another Player of a violation of the rules. The Judge will determine if the accused Player is guilty and, if guilty will determine the punishment. A Player found guilty may ask for a decision to be overturned. The decision of the Judge may be overturned by a unanamious vote, which the Judge and the accused Player will not be allowed to vote. The decision of the vote may not be overturned.

It doesn't make sense that the accuser is allowed to vote in what needs to be a unanimous decision. Also, there seems to be no reason to exclude the accused, since by implication they think they're not guilty.