Tell her you know another way
From Create Your Own Story
"I'm not sure I'm ready for this babe. But maybe if we start somewhere else I'll warm up to it." You tell her.
"Okay babe, I understand. Do you want me to suck your dick?" She asks.
"No I was thinking of another hole." You respond cheekily.
"I don't have a pussy anymore babe." She expresses.
"What about your ass?" You respond.
"Well I know we tried before and it didn't really work but... I don't know if I'm ready to try again. I think it's to tight." She says cautiously.
She's right last time we tried I couldn't get it in. Her ass is really tight.
"Trust me, it'll feel good. You can jerk off while I fuck your ass." You propose.
"Well okay... I guess so..." She replies with hesitation.
She pulls her pants off completely now. Her cock semi erect hanging there. You grab her hips and turn her around. Your cock now pressed against her ass cheek. She trembles a little. She's scared but you know she loves being dominated. You push her over into doggystyle position. Her tight asshole right in front of you. You rub you cock between her ass cheeks and caress her hole. She moans a little. You position your cock right up against her ass. Slowly you push your now thick and throbbing cock into her ass. She whimpers but you keep going. The tip of your cock is in her ass now. Your dying to stuff the rest in.
"Wait, I don't think I can take it. My virgin ass is too tight." She says with worry.
You push on her back with your superior strength. She collapses flat on the bed. Now laying flat on her stomach, you pin her legs using yours and hold her down with one hand on the back of her neck. The other hand supporting your weight. She reaches her arms around to try to grab yours but it's useless. Her arms flail around with little strength. She likes to resist, we've always had a safe word. It allows her to say things that would otherwise make it clear she wanted to stop.
"Please don't fuck my ass." She says in a muffled tone. Her face half in stuffed in a pillow.
"Oh I'm going to, and you're going to take every inch of it." You reply
"Auugh...mfffff..." She's squirming and grabbing my arms with hers.
I tighten my grip around the back of her neck and push my hips forward. My cock penetrating further into her tight little asshole. She yells into the pillow as I push deeper and deeper until my hips are resting on her ass cheeks. My entire cock is buried in her ass. I pull back a little and then thrust forward again, and again. I'm now fully fucking her tight little ass. She screams and moans as I begin to pound harder and harder.
"Do you like having your tight little ass pounded?" I ask her without stoping.
"FUUUUCK....I...CANT...TAKE...IT!" She screams back loudly enough to hear over my cock pounding into her.
"Are you my little slut?" You ask.
IM....YOUR..SLUT....DADDY....YOU..CAN...USE..MY...HOLES! She screams.
You pound her asshole over and over. But what next