You start fucking her asshole

From Create Your Own Story

You insert your penis into her asshole. She screams in pain and you can tell this is her first time having sex. You can feel how tight it is and it feels great. You don't want to stop, but it looks like Emily's in real pain by the expression on her face. Do you:

• Keep thrusting back and forth as you reach orgasm
• Take out your penis and give Emily time to recover