Piggy's Day/You shouldn't
From Create Your Own Story
Piggy: "Oh yeah? I'll show that old coot what us new-generation fishermen are made of!"
You hook up some bait and lower it into the water. By coincidence, you happened to anchor your boat right next to a small, but deep underwater ravine. The hook falls straight in there. Here, all kinds of weird creatures inhabit the jagged rock walls.
Your bait is eaten by: