Order everyone to fire at the eye at once
From Create Your Own Story
You, the girl and Paul fire at the ugly thing's eye. You hit it with so much firepower its head blows up. The three of you lower your weapons. "It's over," you say, when all of the sudden you see the thing rise up. A huge eyeball pops out of its head and it swings its arm at you knocking the guns out of you hands. You look at its giant eyeball and think, "I still have the knife..."
Do you
or