Pop your pecker out of the mermaid

From Create Your Own Story

You withdraw from her snatch, tuck yourself back into your pants, and stand up. She smiles up at you, looking quite satisfied and well fucked.

"I think my pussy is more sensitive than it was when I had legs," the redhead says. "It's worth being like this if the sex is always going to be that intense. Um. But I think I should get to someplace wet now. I'm not made for land anymore."

Do you:

• Leave the mermaid helpless on the costume shop floor
• Pick the mermaid up in your arms