You promise Kara that you'll be gentle and will tell her what to do
From Create Your Own Story
"Kara, it's OK. We'll go slow. If it hurts too much, we'll stop."
Kara snuggles against you, her hard nipples pushing into your chest. You sit down on the toilet, then pull her onto your lap, sideways, so that your erect cock is sticking up between her thighs. Slowly you slide your hand up her inner thigh; she moans as your fingers brush the lips of her vagina, gasps as you part them and gently work the end of your index finger against her clitoris. She takes your cock in her hand, excitedly stroking it, to the point that you have to tell her to slow down so that you don't cum.
Her vagina is getting wetter and wetter, and she scoots herself forward on your lap so that your erection is against the lips of her pussy, rocking her hips so that her clitoris rubs against the head of your cock. "I think I'm ready", she whispers.
You turn her around so that she is facing you, straddling you where you sit on the toilet. "Just slide down on it, sweetie" you whisper. "If it hurts, don't force it. It will probably hurt a little bit." You are a little bit worried - Kara is a small girl, and your cock is a hell of a lot bigger than most dudes' - you hope that, as a virgin, it won't be too much for her.
Kara slowly lowers herself. She takes your cock in her hand, guiding it towards her. You reach between her legs and spread her lips gently. She gasps as the massive head of your cock touches her, and pauses for an instant, then continues to lower herself. A little cry of pain escapes her as your cock slowly makes its way inside of her. Her face is screwed up, brows knitted, and after taking an inch or so of your cock into her body she suddenly stands up.
"Are you OK, sweetie?"
She nods. "Yeah, it's OK. It just hurts a little bit. Let me try again."
Kara guides your cock into her body again. She breathes deeply, trying to relax. "Why won't it go in any farther? Is that my virginity?"
You tell her that it is her hymen, and that breaking it will hurt, but that once it's done it will be easier. Kara nods, her eyes closed. "I can't do it myself. You break it."
You put your hands on Kara's shoulders, kiss her, and slowly but firmly pull down. You feel her hymen tear, feel her body shudder as your cock buries itself within her.
