Have them turn her over and take her virginity from behind

From Create Your Own Story

You've already popped one cherry tonight. You're pretty sure that you'll have that same opportunity with Katy, if you so wish. "Put her on her hands and knees. I'm going to fuck her like a dog."

Without much trouble and more than a few smirks the guys turn her over, though she is still kicking and struggling. Again her legs are caught and held down, her preteen pussy exposed to you and all the guys in the room, as if begging to be filled with your cum. She is trembling and shaking, but you're too filled with lust and desire to care.

You move up behind Katy, and your cock bumps against her ass. She gives a shriek and tries to scramble away on her hands and knees, but the jocks are holding on to her too well, and she's not that strong. You start to line up your cock with her pussy, and realize she's neither that wet nor that big, so you drool a long trail of spit onto the head of your cock. Then you wedge it into place against her opening, sliding it up and down a little to distribute the saliva over her.

"Chad!" Katy pleads desperately. You glance at his direction. He's just staring with a bit of a deer in the headlights look, and then takes a long drink from a glass of something.

You puts your hands on Katy's slim waist and start pushing yourself into her. Of course, she's a virgin. That only works to slow you down, as you jerk your hips forward, and tear apart her hymen.

"You're hurting me!" she screams, her entire body shaking.

"Looks like Josh here is a real cherry-popper," one the jocks said. "That's two today." That brings a cheer from the other guys. There's even a muffled cheer from Miranda, who seems to be a little out of it as she continues to get fucked.

The support of your new peers gives you even more confidence, so you slowly start fucking Katy, making her wail with every thrust into her newly-violated pussy. She tries feebly to crawl off of your cock, but her scrambling arms and legs make no headway against the jocks holding her in place. They're probably actually overkill, as there's only so hard a girl her age can effectively struggle against someone your size.

She loosens up as your plow her, and begins to lubricate more. She doesn't seem to be enjoying it much still, but she's struggling less. She doesn't even notice when the jocks let go of her. Your hands firmly on her waist are enough to keep her in place. The only moving she's doing is as her body gets thrown forward with every thrust.

"Josh..." you hear Chad say softly. He's just a few feet from you. "At least don't cum inside of her." He looks embarrassed. "I know she's really young and shit, but I think she's already had a period." He looks at Miranda. "Fucking your sister is fine, because she can't get pregnant. But I don't even know how I'm going to keep all... this with her under wraps, let alone her getting knocked up."